Skip to content
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin • 800-438-6878

Current outgoing shipping days are Mon, Wed, Thu, and Fri.
Open Daily, 10 AM – 5 PM • Middleton, Wisconsin •
800-438-6878

Current outgoing shipping days are Mon, Wed, Thu, and Fri.

Mustard of the Month Subscription

A full year of premium mustard awaits you!

At the start of each month, we provide a trio of curated mustards along with an exclusive newsletter that contains recipes and serving ideas. That's a total of 36 mustards over the course of a year!

If you don't have room in your pantry to fit three dozen jars of delicious mustard, worry not! Opt for the Every Other subscription to receive a delivery every two months, for a total of 18 mustards. If you only require the occasional mustard restock, select the Quarterly subscription to receive a box for every season, or 12 mustards total.

Delayed Start Month

If you select a start month in the dropdown menu below, remember to indicate on the Cart page that your preferred ship date is within your chosen start month.

Subscription Cancellation

If you select any of the one-year plans (Monthly, Every Other, or Quarterly), you are paying for one whole year of mustard up-front. You may receive a Subscription Cancellation notification after you check out. This is to let you know that your credit card won't be charged again. You will receive the full year of mustard you paid for, and you won't be automatically signed up for another year.

If you select the Month-to-Month plan, you will be charged for each month's box until you cancel your subscription. To cancel or manage your subscription, follow the link to your customer portal in the email you received after checkout.

Shipping Details

The price includes regular ground shipping (we will send UPS or USPS, at our discretion) to all valid addresses in the continental United States. For other shipping methods or locations, contact us for additional shipping charges.




Loading subscriptions ...